7 Effective Strategies for Increasing Your Instagram Engagement

“Steal my strategy!” “Here’s what I posted to reach 100K followers!” 

This ain’t that, I promise. 

If you rolled your eyes at that first line, you’re in the right place. 

Every business is different, so following someone else’s Instagram strategy or post schedule is unlikely to work for you. And everyone’s goals are different – some businesses focus on reaching new customers and others focus on having a super engaged customer base. Which means their strategies will be different. 

But there are foundational social media strategies, better known as best practices, that work for every business. Here are 7 effective strategies that any business will benefit from. 

1. Know Your Customer

The most effective strategy for increasing your Instagram engagement (or achieving any marketing goal, for that matter) is to know your customer. 

Once you know who your customer is, marketing your business becomes simple, streamlined, and crazy effective. 

But we’re not talking about demographics here. Age, gender, and location is a starting point, but that’s not how you get to know someone. 

You want to know where they hang out online, what kind of language they use, the pop culture they’re interested in, what their problem actually is, and exactly what they need to click ‘add to cart’. Then you’ll know exactly where to market your business, how to connect with them, and what to say.

What you need is a customer persona, and here’s how to get it. 

2. Speak to Your Customer, NOT to Everyone

Once you know who your customer is, you can talk to them, and NOT to everyone. 

What do I mean by that? 

When you use vague statements, generic words, and ultimately try to appeal to everyone, you end up appealing to no one. 

Instead, you want your target customer to read your marketing and think “OMG they’re talking to me – this is exactly what I’ve been struggling with, this is totally how I feel, and they have the perfect solution!” 

When your customer has this lightbulb moment, they’re going to engage with your post (hello likes, comments, shares, and saves) AND they’re going to buy. Which is the end goal, right? 

Whether it’s your social media caption, your email newsletter, or an ad campaign, get my three step process for learning how to write marketing messaging that converts. 

3. Create Scroll-Stopping Visual Content

You know who your customer is and you’ve got marketing messaging that speaks to them, but what about the visual content? Social media is visual – even if it’s a classic grid post – and as a SMM, I think the visual component is vastly overlooked. One of the biggest mistakes I see small business owners make is posting ecommerce product photos, photos that are blurry or dimly lit, or the same ten photos over and over. 

Don’t make this mistake. 

Instead, invest in a product photographer (you can email me for my faves!), learn how to take high-quality photos yourself, or play around in Canva or Photoshop (like this launch post I created because we didn’t have photos).

Another way to create scroll-stopping Instagram content is to invest in social media templates for your grid posts, stories, and reel covers. The templates will make it so easy to quickly create a consistent look and feel for every single Instagram post. 

Get more Instagram design tips here!

4. Take Advantage of On-Screen Hooks

When you create a reel you should have at least three hooks:

• A verbal hook (what you say)
• A hook in the caption
• An on-screen hook 
• *If you’re sharing your reel to stories, you should add a fourth hook here!

An “on-screen hook” could be text on the screen like this, or it could be motion like this, or even an action throughout the video like this. 

5. Use a Strong & Unique Hook Statement

You know you need at least three hooks, but what hooks actually work? How do you write one yourself? How do you know if it’s strong enough? 

You can absolutely steal hooks from a social media manager – we share them all the time! 

But that’s not really sustainable, is it? Your customers will get bored with the same five hooks over and over. 

I teach you how to write an effective hook statement here, but the short & sweet version is this: use a question, an introduction to a dramatic story, or a startling statistic.

Use questions like “Did you know…” if your customers like to learn new things. Try using a story to share a lesson that your customers can learn from, as long as it’s connected to your brand and products. Slide in a statistic if you want to really stop their scroll.

Get my hook sentence checklist here to make sure you’re using the strongest, most captivating hook sentences. 

If you’re in a pinch and want to get started asap, download 50 hook statements here (plus 20 call to actions!). 

6. Include an Engagement-Driving Call to Action

I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again: if you’re not using a call to action, your content is not as effective as it could be. I promise. 

In this case, skipping a call to action is leaving likes, comments, shares, and saves on the table! As much as your customer might’ve liked your post, they’re less likely to “like” your post if you don’t remind them. 

When you’re trying to increase your Instagram engagement, use an engagement-driving call to action, like: 

• Like this post if you found it helpful
• Share this with someone who needs to know
• Comment your least favourite part about [customer problem]
• Save this post for your next [product-related experience]

If you’re already using engagement-driving CTAs but you aren’t getting much engagement, consider if your content is actually providing value. Is it something your customers will find helpful? Something they’d want to share with their friends or save for later? Because no amount of CTAs will make up for boring content. 

Download 20 call to action ideas here. You’ll also get  my step-by-step process for creating CTAs that’ll work for your customers.

7. Simplify Your Messaging

Last but not least: simplify your messaging. 

Our attention spans are shorter than ever. You have about 8 seconds before your customer’s eyes wander elsewhere, so you’ve got to make them count. 

If your messaging is complex and filled with industry jargon, customers are going to scroll away. They don’t want to spend time looking up terms or trying to understand what you’re saying. They want entertaining content that’s easy to understand. 

Use words that are easy to understand, short and clear sentences, and keep your messaging brief. Use a strong hook, introduce the problem, identify your product as the solution, and end with an engagement-driving call to action. Boom, done. 

If only it was that easy, right? 😉

For post ideas to increase your engagement, download 45 Free Post Ideas here. 

To learn how to understand your customer, check out this blog post. 

If you don’t know what to post on Instagram stories anymore (one of the best places for Instagram engagement!), read these ideas. 

---

First things first, hi! I’m Sarah—social media manager for food & wellness brands. If you liked this blog post and want more marketing tips, tricks, and bev recs, here are a few ways to do just that:

Subscribe to my weekly newsletter! Each week I send new marketing tips, trends, and a flavour of the week. It’s the best way to stay up-to-date and in-the-know, right from your inbox. Click here to subscribe!

Scroll through the blog. If you liked this blog post, you’ll probably like the rest. Scroll through to snag my tried & true social media marketing tips. Spoiler alert: I’m sharing all my secrets.

Get the social media support your business deserves. I can manage your Instagram and TikTok accounts, audit your social media, create your new marketing strategy, take on your email marketing, and more.

Explore the social media shop. Each product is designed for entrepreneurs who want social media to feel easy.

To get in touch with me personally, slide into my DMs or send an email to hi@sarahprice.co.